top of page

Whose Bill Is It Anyway?

seanwhuds
13 minutes ago
5 min read

When politicians and billionaires battle over sports funding

Paycom Center, Oklahoma City. Photo: Kerwin Moore, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Paycom Center, Oklahoma City. Photo: Kerwin Moore, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

 

Owners of the Oklahoma City Thunder and the city of Oklahoma City have agreed to build a brand-new, state-of-the-art arena, Continental Coliseum, for the market's only major professional sports team. The city has committed to spend at least $900 million, and builder Mortenson estimates the project at about $990 million. Construction is targeted for completion by late summer 2028, with a contractual hard deadline of June 2029. So where is the money coming from?

 

The Oklahoma City Thunder's owners are expected to contribute $50 million.

 

Taxpayers are expected to cover the remaining $850 million or more, through $89 million in MAPS 4 funds and a six-year extension of the city's one-cent sales tax. Voters approved the tax in December 2023 with 71% support.

 

Oklahoma native and former NBA star Blake Griffin recently used his podcast to address the matter.

 

 

As Griffin correctly points out, Oklahoma City has very little leverage in this situation. OKC is a single-team city, and the owners could simply pack up their ball and leave. After all, that is exactly how the franchise got to Oklahoma City, leaving Seattle as the SuperSonics in 2008.

 

The Thunder posted a report summarizing the deal and the benefits that will come of it, which include:

 

  • The team stays in OKC

  • Oklahoma-based businesses will complete the construction

  • Local restaurants will be featured in the arena by third-party caterer Levy

  • The new arena will host events beyond basketball games

 

The team stays in OKC

 

This one feels the most obvious. The team's owners can use risk aversion to motivate local policymakers to agree to the funding. Plenty of other markets, such as Las Vegas, Nashville and Baltimore, would happily accept an NBA franchise.

 

Oklahoma-based businesses will complete the construction

 

Tulsa-based Flintco is building the arena in a joint venture with Minneapolis-based Mortenson, and Oklahoma City's Dolese Bros. is supplying the concrete. This feels a bit like the broken window fallacy in economics. Yes, these Oklahoma-based organizations will be awarded large contracts to complete the work. Yes, 99% of their employees are Oklahoma residents. However, the money funding those contracts comes from taxpayers.

 

Local restaurants will be featured in the arena by third-party caterer Levy

 

This feels like the biggest stretch of all the benefits listed in the report. I am a firm believer that sports teams should take on the identity of their host city. Many professional sports teams use third-party caterers such as Levy Restaurants to handle their concessions and premium-seating catering. I'm not sure how many people have ever had food inside an arena or stadium and been moved to the point that they would go out of their way to find that food outside the venue. While it is imperative that the new arena have an organic “taste” of Oklahoma City, I would not justify $850 million in taxpayer money to do it.

 

The new arena will host events beyond basketball games

 

This is probably one of the strongest cases to support building any new sporting facility. I do not do math in front of other people, so I will use a calculator. There are 365 days in a year. The NBA plays 82 games in a regular season. Forty-one of those are home games. That leaves 324 days and nights when the new arena will not be occupied by a professional basketball game. (There are ancillary events to a basketball season, such as preseason and postseason, but for simplicity, let's go with this number.) Newer venues can host bigger, better-produced concerts, and they can do so more often. While figures are not set in stone, a host venue and promoter typically retain around 15% to 20% of event revenue.

 

So when does an investment in a professional sports facility make sense for a local government? What do Philadelphia, New York City and Washington, D.C., have in common? Location, location, location.

 

All three are major metropolitan areas, and all three are close to the borders of other states. There is a real argument to be made that many fans coming to these arenas will travel from other states. The 76ers can draw fans from New Jersey and Delaware. The Knicks can do so from New Jersey, Connecticut and Pennsylvania. And the Wizards can draw fans from Northern Virginia, Southern Maryland and even parts of West Virginia. Without the team, those fans from outside your borders would likely spend their time and money in their own market by going to a restaurant, seeing a play or staying home. Instead, your city, state or district has encouraged tourism and brought that spending to you.

 

To compare, let's take a look at Oklahoma City. The closest sizable out-of-state city is Wichita Falls, Texas, about 140 miles and roughly 2 hours and 15 minutes from downtown Oklahoma City. Wichita, Kansas, is a bit farther, at about 160 miles and 2 hours and 20 minutes. My questions: How many fans are making that trip, and are there enough of them to justify using sports as an economic driver?


So whose bill is it? Right now, it belongs to the people of Oklahoma City. I understand why voters said yes. Nobody wants to be the next Seattle, and the Thunder's owners know that. But a $50 million contribution on a project that could pass $990 million is not much of a partnership. Concerts and other events will help the building earn its keep, but Oklahoma City does not have the out-of-state crowd that makes these deals pay off in places like Philadelphia or Washington. If the owners want this arena to feel like Oklahoma City's home, they should pay like it's their home too.

 

Sources

 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page